Topic 7 · Differentiation

Stationary points, maxima and minima

ASSpec 7.355 min9 questions

9 practice questions

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Find the coordinates of stationary points by solving
  • Classify a stationary point using the second derivative
  • Use a sign test when the second derivative is zero
  • Solve optimisation problems, and justify that the answer is a maximum or minimum

Worth doing first: Differentiating powers of x, Second derivatives and the gradient function

The idea

A stationary point is a point where the curve is momentarily flat: the gradient is zero. These are the interesting points on a graph — the peaks, the troughs, and the occasional flat spot on the way past — and they are what optimisation problems are really asking about.

Classifying them

Knowing where a curve is flat does not tell you whether it is a peak or a trough. The second derivative settles it, because it measures which way the curve bends.

Three kinds of stationary point: a maximum where the curve turns downward, a minimum where it turns upward, and a point of inflection where the curve flattens but carries on in the same direction. maximum f''(x) < 0 minimum f''(x) > 0 inflection f''(x) = 0
The three cases. A horizontal tangent is not enough on its own to say which you have.
At a stationary point Conclusion
Minimum — the curve is convex, holding water
Maximum — the curve is concave, spilling water
Inconclusive — it could be any of the three. Use a sign test

When the second derivative is zero

proves nothing on its own. has a clear minimum at the origin yet ; has an inflection there with the same second derivative. When this happens, fall back on a sign test: evaluate just to the left and just to the right of the stationary point.

just left just rightConclusion
negativepositiveMinimum
positivenegativeMaximum
same sign both sidesPoint of inflection — the curve flattens but carries on

Optimisation

This is where the topic earns its keep. The pattern is always the same, and most of the work is in the first step rather than the calculus:

  1. Write the quantity to be optimised as a formula.
  2. If it involves two variables, use the constraint given in the question to eliminate one, so you have a function of a single variable.
  3. Differentiate, set equal to zero, and solve.
  4. Justify that it is the maximum or minimum you wanted, using .
  5. Answer the question actually asked — often the optimal value, not the that produces it.

Worked examples

4 fully worked
Example 16 marks
Find the coordinates of the stationary points on the curve , and determine their nature.
  1. Differentiate and set equal to zero.

  2. Find the -coordinates from the original equation.

  3. Now classify, using the second derivative.

Example 26 marks
Find the stationary points on the curve and determine their nature.
  1. Rewrite as a power before differentiating.

  2. Set equal to zero and solve. Multiply through by to clear the fraction.

  3. Differentiate again.

  4. Worth noticing: this maximum sits below this minimum. "Maximum" means locally highest, not highest overall — the two branches of the curve never meet.

Example 36 marks
The curve has stationary points at and . Determine the nature of each.
  1. At the second derivative is decisive.

  2. At it is not.

  3. So use a sign test on either side of .

  4. The gradient is negative on both sides, so the curve is falling before and after. It flattens for an instant without turning: a point of inflection at .

Example 48 marks
An open-topped box has a square base of side cm and a volume of cm. Show that its external surface area is , and find the value of that minimises .
  1. Let the height be . The base is and there are four sides, each . There is no lid.

  2. Use the volume constraint to eliminate .

  3. Now differentiate, writing the fraction as a power first.

  4. Set equal to zero.

  5. Justify that this is a minimum — this step carries a mark.

  6. Positive, so it is a minimum. The box uses least material when the base is cm square, giving cm.

Practice

23 marks in total

Type your answer and press Check. Any algebraically equivalent form is accepted — 3x^2 - 4x, -4x + 3x^2 and x(3x - 4) all count as the same answer. Use ^ for powers, sqrt(x) for roots, and brackets wherever you are unsure.

1Warm-up2 marks
Given , find .
2Exam standard3 marks
The curve has one stationary point. Find its -coordinate.
3Exam standard3 marks
Given , find .
4Exam standard3 marks
For the curve , find the value of at .
5Warm-up1 mark
A curve has a stationary point at , where . What is the nature of this stationary point?
Choose one answer
6Exam standard3 marks
An open-topped box with a square base of side cm has surface area . Find .
7Exam standard2 marks
For that box, the surface area is least when . Find the minimum surface area, in cm.
8Exam standard2 marks
Given , find .
9Stretch4 marks
A rectangle has perimeter cm and width cm, so its area is . Find the width that maximises the area.